Build Your Own Cookie Box | New York Style Cookies

Build your own cookie box with our New York Style Chunky Cookies, choosing your favourite flavours to create your perfect combination. Each oversized cookie is freshly baked with a soft, gooey centre, crisp golden edges and generous chunks of premium chocolate and fillings. Choose from Pistachio & White Belgian Chocolate, Triple Chocolate, Nutella, Biscoff, Mars or S’mores, with a minimum order of 2 cookies and freshly baked cookie delivery available across mainland UK.

Handmade in Hertfordshire and freshly baked for every order.

Available Shipping:

Gift card available for national delivery:

A hand written gift card can be added to your order for free, at checkout.

Description

If choosing just one flavour feels impossible, our New York Style Chunky Cookies Build Your Own Box lets you create the perfect combination. Choose a minimum of 2 Cookies, then mix and match your favourite flavours and select as many of each as you like. We’ll freshly bake your selection before carefully packing your cookies for collection from Cinnamon Square or delivery across mainland UK.

Inspired by the famous New York bakery style, these are proper chunky cookies. Generously sized, crisp and lightly caramelised on the outside, irresistibly soft and gooey in the middle, and packed with indulgent fillings, every cookie is designed to deliver that full bakery experience from the very first bite.

Choose from a growing selection of flavours:

Pistachio & White Belgian Chocolate A chunky cookie packed with pistachio nibs and Belgian white chocolate chunks. Filled and topped with smooth pistachio cream, then finished with chopped pistachios and a drizzle of Belgian white chocolate.
Triple Chocolate A rich chocolate cookie made with dark cocoa powder and packed with Belgian milk and white chocolate chunks. Deeply chocolatey, indulgent and loaded with chocolate in every bite.
Nutella A rich chocolate cookie packed with dark Belgian chocolate chunks and pieces of roasted hazelnut. Filled and topped with Nutella, then finished with a sprinkling of chopped hazelnuts.
Biscoff A chunky cookie filled with smooth Biscoff cream, topped with more Biscoff cream and finished with a Lotus Biscoff biscuit. Rich, spiced & unmistakably Biscoff.
Mars Bar Our rich chocolate cookie filled with a gooey caramel centre, topped with Belgian milk chocolate and finished with a chunk of Mars Bar. Rich, gooey and seriously indulgent.
S’mores A rich, buttery cookie filled with Belgian milk chocolate and marshmallow, then topped with toasted marshmallow. Inspired by the classic campfire favourite, with a soft, gooey centre.

Whether you prefer rich chocolate, creamy hazelnut, caramelised Biscoff or nutty pistachio, you can build a cookie box that is completely your own. Choose two of the same flavour, mix several favourites or create a larger selection for sharing – there is no maximum overall quantity.

Our New York Style Chunky Cookies are handmade in our Hertfordshire bakery using carefully selected ingredients and baked fresh for your order. They are delicious enjoyed straight from the box, but for the ultimate experience we recommend warming each cookie for around 15–20 seconds in the microwave. The centre becomes wonderfully soft and gooey while the chocolate and fillings melt into every bite.

The New York Style Chunky Cookies Build Your Own Box makes a brilliant gift, dessert, office treat or weekend indulgence. Add a handwritten gift message and send freshly baked cookies directly to friends, family or colleagues, with mainland UK delivery available Wednesday to Saturday. Alternatively, order online for collection from Cinnamon Square in Rickmansworth, Hertfordshire, Tuesday to Saturday.

However you build your box, you’ll enjoy bakery-quality cookies handmade with the same care and attention to detail that has made Cinnamon Square known for award-winning baking.

National Delivery Information

This product is available for delivery between Wednesday – Saturday. We send our products via a trackable, next day national delivery courier. PLEASE NOTE, THIS IS NOT A 100% GUARANTEED NEXT DAY SERVICE. If you need your buns delivered for a specific date, please consider ordering for delivering the day before required, as services can occasionally be delayed due to unforeseeable circumstances. We are unable to ship to Ireland, Northern Ireland, the Scottish Islands, Scottish Highlands, Channel Isles, Isle of Man, Isle of Wight, and Scilly Isles. Please see our FAQ page for more information.

Ingredients

Pistachio & White Chocolate New York Style Cookie
Wheat flour, sugar, butter (milk), pistachio cream (pistachio (nuts), milk, soya), Belgian white chocolate (sugar, cocoa butter, milk powder, emulsifier (soya lecithin 322), natural vanilla flavour), egg, skimmed milk powder, corn flour, glucose syrup, raising agents (mono-calcium phosphate, sodium bicarbonate).

Nutella New York Style Cookie
Wheat flour, sugar, butter (milk), Nutella (sugar, palm oil, hazelnuts (nuts), skimmed milk powder, fat-reduced cocoa, emulsifier: soya lecithin, vanillin), Belgian chocolate (cocoa mass, sugar, cocoa butter, milk powder, emulsifier (soya lecithin 322), natural vanilla flavour), egg, cocoa powder, hazelnuts (nuts), skimmed milk powder, corn flour, glucose syrup, raising agents (mono-calcium phosphate, sodium bicarbonate).

S’mores New York Style Cookie
Wheat flour, sugar, butter (milk), Belgian chocolate (cocoa mass, sugar, cocoa butter, skimmed milk powder, emulsifier (soya lecithin 322), natural vanilla flavour), marshmallow (egg, sulphites), skimmed milk powder, egg, corn flour, glucose syrup, raising agents (mono-calcium phosphate, sodium bicarbonate).

Triple Chocolate New York Style Cookie
Wheat flour, sugar, butter (milk), Belgian chocolate (cocoa mass, sugar, cocoa butter, milk powder, emulsifier (soya lecithin 322), natural vanilla flavour), egg, cocoa powder, skimmed milk powder, corn flour, glucose syrup, raising agents (mono-calcium phosphate, sodium bicarbonate).

Biscoff New York Style Cookie
Wheat flour, sugar, butter (milk), Biscoff spread (original caramelised biscuits 58% (wheat flour, sugar, vegetable oils (palm oil from sustainable and certified plantations, rapeseed oil), sugar syrup, raising agent (sodium hydrogen carbonate), soya flour, salt, cinnamon), rapeseed oil, sugar, emulsifier (soya lecithin), acid (citric acid), Belgian white chocolate (sugar, cocoa butter, milk powder, emulsifier (soya lecithin 322), natural vanilla flavour), egg, ground cinnamon, skimmed milk powder, corn flour, glucose syrup, caramel, raising agents (mono-calcium phosphate, sodium bicarbonate).

Mars Bar New York Style Cookie
Wheat flour, sugar, butter (milk), Mars Bar (sugar, glucose syrup, skimmed milk powder, cocoa butter, cocoa mass, sunflower oil, palm fat, lactose (milk), whey permeate (milk), fat-reduced cocoa, barley malt extract, soya lecithin, salt, egg white powder), egg, cocoa powder, skimmed milk powder, corn flour, glucose syrup, raising agents (mono-calcium phosphate, sodium bicarbonate).

Allergen advice: see ingredients in bold

Frequently Asked Questions

How does the Build Your Own Cookie Box work?

Choose your favourite New York Style Chunky Cookies and select how many of each flavour you would like. You can mix and match the flavours to create your own box, with a minimum order of 2 cookies.

How much are the New York Style Chunky Cookies?

Each cookie is £4, regardless of flavour. Simply choose the quantity of each flavour you would like and the price of your box will be calculated automatically. The minimum order is 2 cookies.

When are the cookies available for delivery?

Our New York Style Chunky Cookies are available for mainland UK delivery Wednesday to Saturday. Choose your preferred available delivery date when placing your order.

Can I collect my Build Your Own Cookie Box?

Yes. You can order your cookies online for collection from Cinnamon Square in Rickmansworth, Hertfordshire, Tuesday to Saturday. Select collection and your preferred available date at checkout.

How should I store my New York Style Chunky Cookies?

Keep your cookies in the original box somewhere cool and dry.

Can I warm my cookies?

Absolutely. Our chunky cookies are particularly delicious served warm, when the centre becomes softer and the chocolate and fillings begin to melt. Warm gently before serving and take care as the fillings may become hot.

Can I freeze the cookies?

Yes. The cookies can be frozen if you would like to keep them for longer. Wrap or store them well before freezing and allow them to defrost thoroughly before serving or gently warming.

Can I send a Build Your Own Cookie Box as a gift?

Yes. Build Your Own Cookie Boxes make a great gift and can be delivered directly to the recipient. You can add a personal gift message when ordering.

Where are Cinnamon Square’s New York Style Chunky Cookies made?

Our New York Style Chunky Cookies are handmade and freshly baked by Cinnamon Square in Hertfordshire, with collection from Rickmansworth and delivery available across mainland UK.

What New York Style Chunky Cookie flavours can I choose from?

Choose from Pistachio & White Belgian Chocolate, Triple Chocolate, Nutella, Biscoff, Mars and S’mores. Pick just one favourite or mix different flavours to create your perfect cookie box.